TravelTravel

Hotel

The Bay Club Hotel & MarinaThe Bay Club Hotel & Marina

For those traveling in, we’ve reserved a stay at the Bay Club Hotel & Marina, a charming waterfront retreat on Shelter Island—because you belong with us for this magical weekend! With shimmering city lights on the water, cozy seaside vibes, and festive holiday décor, this hotel is the perfect place to stay and soak in the holiday magic. Guests can unwind by the heated outdoor pool (no cardigans required), sip a warm drink at the on-site restaurant (champagne problems, anyone?), or take a stroll along the glittering marina. And best of all? It’s just a short drive to Liberty Station, where we’ll be dancing and saying I do under the glow of sparkling lights. So whether you’re sipping wine in the bathtub (or hot cocoa on your private balcony), enjoying the gold rush of ocean air, or getting into the holiday spirit, we hope your time with us turns into a piece of folklore that you'll always remember as part of our love story. ***PLEASE NOTE*** Room reservations must be made by Tuesday, November 11, 2025 to receive the discounted group rate of $179.00 per night. For more information, click the link below to see available room types and policy information.