Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen (Port Jefferson) Southdown Coffee (Port Jefferson) Local’s Café (Port Jefferson) Toast Coffee + Kitchen (Port Jefferson) Nearby Towns: Soul Brew (St. James) Seaqua Deli (St. James) - Narali & Jared's Favorite BEC Spot! 🥓🍳 Druthers Coffee (Stony Brook) The Bench (Stony Brook Village Green) Crazy Beans (Stony Brook)
The Pie Nantucket's Prohibition Kitchen & Cocktails Old Field's Castaway's Pasta Pasta PJ Lobster House The Fifth Season The Stone Goat Restaurant & Brewery (St. James) Black Pearl Seafood Chophouse (📍Welcome Drinks venue!)
Tommy’s Place (📍 After-Party Location!) Billie’s 1890 Saloon Tara Inn The Whiskey Barrel Port Jefferson Brewing Company (Tasting room — bring your own food!)
*Stroll Main Street in Port Jefferson, the heart of this charming harbor village *Stop by Dortoni’s Bakery for Italian pastries, decadent cakes, and rich espresso *Treat yourself to Chandler Square Ice Cream — a local favorite (and Taglialavore family favorite) year-round! *Visit the Port Jefferson Village Center or the Maritime Explorium for history & maritime vibes *Unwind at Harborfront Park and enjoy peaceful waterfront views *Explore the Long Island Museum (Stony Brook) — art, history & carriage collection *Take a trip east to Jason’s Vineyard (45–50 minutes), where Jared proposed to Narali! Enjoy wine tastings, live music, and a charming farm atmosphere *Take a day trip to NYC via train from Port Jefferson or St. James to Penn Station or Grand Central