He thought my pizza order was pretentious (he's right), and I thought he was way too into himself (I'm right). Despite all this, the date ended with running in the pouring rain and belting out Phil Collins in the car. Knoxville, Tenn.

Andy and I were on the way to the Baltimore airport to head on an Alaskan cruise with his family, and he suggested we stop by one of my favorite vineyards in Northern Virginia to grab a bottle of wine for our trip. Before we headed back out on the road, we each grabbed a drink to enjoy outside while taking in the view. Andy said some really sweet things, got down on one knee, pulled out a beautiful ring and then I blacked out ...but I'm 99% sure he asked me to marry him. Hillsborough Vineyard in Hillsboro, Va.