Cris and Courtney matched on Hinge, but Courtney was pretty over the whole dating app scene. After Cris sent her a long, thoughtful message, she left him on “read”. Three days later, while riding in an Uber with her friend Erika, Cris sent another message—this one so charming it made Courtney smile. She showed it to Erika, who immediately said, “You have to text him back!” Courtney did, and thank goodness, because that one reply turned into a love story they’ll never forget.