This is one of our all-time favorite restaurants. They focus on whole-animal butchery and have delicious craft cocktails. Their menu changes daily so make sure to visit their website to see what's cookin' that day. They have grab-and-go options available as well - perfect for a picnic!
There are many options on the island. See the attached Seattle Times article for their recommendations.
This is Brody's recommended thing to do on the island since we saw a lizard on the trail during a hike here (like he used to chase in Tucson). A local confirmed that lizards do live on the island (Ashley thought she was seeing things)!