Hotel
This is the closest conventional hotel. There are some B&Bs in Mathews/Gloucester area in addition to the Hampton Inn.
Hotel
This is right next door to the Hampton Inn, if you wanted some variety. There is also a Wendy's next door that a teenage Harry used to frequent regularly.
House Or Rental
Harry and Autumn rent out cottages here frequently, and they are pet friendly! Its right on the water, with great fishing, a pool, boat launches, etc.
Hotel
Williamsburg has plenty of hotel options, this is only one of them. Autumn and Harry have stayed here before, and it is decent and well priced. It is further away from the ceremony and reception, maximum is 45 minutes from Williamsburg to Mathews.
Hotel
This hotel is very nice, especially if you plan on touring around before or after the wedding. Colonial Williamsburg also has guest accommodations in the Historic Area as well, if you've ever wanted to stay in a colonial house.