Hotel
A historic hotel in Shelter Island Heights, less than a 10-minute walk from the North Ferry and surrounded by shops, cafés, and restaurants. You’ll need a car or bike to reach the beach. We’ve reserved a room block here. To book, click "Filters" on the rooms page and enter B359152 under "Promo/Group Code." You should then see "Abby & Robert" listed under each room type.
Hotel
A four-room bed and breakfast overlooking Chase Creek, located on a quiet lane within walking distance of town shops and restaurants. Bike rentals are available, and beaches are a short drive away. We have reserved all four rooms here. If you would like to stay here, please text Robert (646-596-5453) or Abby (646-257-0560).
Hotel
A small, cozy inn located near the center of Shelter Island. Rooms are simple and comfortable with a homey feel. You will need a bike, car, or taxi to access local shops, restaurants and beaches. We have reserved all seven rooms here. If you would like to stay here, please text Robert (646-596-5453) or Abby (646-257-0560).
Hotel
A classic waterfront hotel overlooking Crescent Beach. Rooms and cottages are spread across a large property with a pool, dock, and lawn. It’s more resort-like, with on-site dining and a quiet, family-friendly atmosphere. A short drive or ride to other parts of the island, and within walking distance to Sunset Beach. Please note, this property requires a three-night minimum stay.
Hotel
This hotel is located in Greenport, not on Shelter Island, but it's within walking distance of the North Ferry. You'll need to take the ferry across to reach the island for the wedding festivities.
Hotel
Click on "view" below for a list of rentals on Shelter Island and Greenport. We have organized the information by number of guests and price for your convenience.