Near Sunset Beach Hotel and Restaurant, this beach is great for swimming and sunset views. Daily parking permits are required via the ParkMobile app.
Small, calm bay beach perfect for swimming. Daily parking permits are required via the ParkMobile app.
Family-friendly spot with calm waters and restrooms. Daily parking permits are required and can be purchased through the ParkMobile app.
Nature preserve with scenic trails and coastal views
On Saturday mornings from late May through Labor Day (9:00 AM–12:30 PM), this outdoor market offers fresh produce, flowers, baked goods, and locally made products.
Guided and self-guided kayak and paddleboard rentals exploring Shelter Island’s waterways
Public 9-hole golf course with scenic views and a casual, historic clubhouse
Casual spot for ice cream, snacks, and mini golf
Cozy waterfront café and market offering fresh pastries, gourmet meals, and coffee—great for breakfast or lunch
Offers breakfast, lunch, and coffee with house-made pastries
Offers a variety of bagels, breakfast sandwiches, salads, and bagel chips, with both classic and creative flavors
Serves fresh, locally sourced seafood, burgers, salads, and cocktails right on the water
Cozy Greenport café known for strong coffee and homemade biscotti
Small-batch craft beers brewed on Shelter Island
Great spot to stop for lunch or dinner on your way back from Shelter Island
Perfect place to pick up pies or fresh fruit on your way home.