Once upon a time in the borough of Queens - Jenna and Matthew attended a New Year's Eve Party at the home of a mutual friend. They had never met but after the ball dropped, they began talking like they had known each other for years. They exchanged numbers and walked into 2009 together.
After visiting good friends in New Jersey they made a quick visit to New York City. Unbeknownst to Jenna, Matthew had conspired with her best friend Derek to find a perfect spot to pop the question. Under the guise of wanting to get a memorable photo, the three walked along the piers of the West Side Highway until there was a skyline suitable for the moment. Once Matthew and Jenna were in position, Matthew dropped down on his knee and asked "Will you marry me?" as Derek kept snapping away capturing the moment.