They met at St. Paul's UMC in Bay Head, with Andrew in a suit and ankle boot and Nicole in her usual. He helped her do some math for the government and thought "there's no way she's single." Nicole thought absolutely nothing of it. Months later they each get an individual phone call from the officiant, Jess, saying, "they said they are interested in you!" But that wasn't the reality, Jess was just "finagling the truth," as Andrew and Nicole would soon find out. Andrew took the chance, sent the text, and they never stopped. Things quickly turned towards forever and on their first anniversary as a couple, he asked the question, and she said "of course I will!"