They were about 6 months into dating. Right in the height of summer and being outside. They were still getting to know each other and still trying to find the right questions to ask that can lead to deeper conversations. It was when they were walking down W 6th St. in Grandview, right next to King Ave, on their way back from walking their dog, Emmy. Sara asked Josh a question that caused him to pause and think: "Do you believe in soulmates?". His response, delayed: "It depends. Do I believe everyone has their perfect match? Yeah. Do I think there could be a few perfect matches? Also, yes." She responded, "Hm. Interesting." On December 22nd, 2025, the day after their engagement in their hot tub, Sara asks the question again: "What's your take on soul mates now?" Josh just smiled and sipped his wine. He knew he wasn't meant to be with anyone else.