Stanley was singing for the likes of Stephen Sondheim and Barbara Cook; Ethan was bootlegging the concert on his iPhone. Stanley's solo? "I'll be seeing you," the romantic ballad and the penultimate song of most Yale Whiffenpoof concerts. (Ethan was a Whiff.) They met in line for pasta and became Facebook friends/stalkers. It took two years, more theater run-ins, and OkCupid to help them finally plan their first date: 9/6/13. After sharing a bowl of punch in the East Village, Ethan confessed he still had that illicit recording of "I'll be seeing you" from years before...