Upon Shay's return from her vacation, she discovered from her roommate Keltie that their friend Kyle had acquired a new puppy named Frank. Excited about this news, they decided to make dinner plans to meet Frank. However, when they arrived, they were surprised to find not only a new puppy but also a new roommate named Devon. It turns out that while Shay was away, Kyle, Keltie, and Devon had arranged this surprise meeting, and the rest, as they say, is history.

In Venice, Italy, Devon carefully planned the perfect proposal during a romantic gondola ride under the Rialto Bridge. After months of preparation, including selecting the perfect ring and timing, he popped the question. Shay's initial reaction was disbelief, as she exclaimed, "Is this a joke?" However, when she realized he was completely serious, she burst into tears of joy, enthusiastically said YES, and the couple awkwardly waved to the cheering crowd that had gathered to witness the special moment.