The Sushi is amazing here! If you go early enough you can watch the sunset and see all the cruise boats heading out. The sharks are always swimming near by- make sure you call and request outdoor seating to see them while you eat!!
We both highly recommend the stingray tour Keith puts on. If you are looking for a good "off resort" option, this is money well spent. The more people you bring on his boat, the better deal it is! Swimming with stingrays should be a MUST when you are visiting Freeport!
This is a great option for a relaxing day, you can snorkel or kayak with sea turtles (who wouldn't want to do this while in the Bahamas?!). They also offer a bar for food and drinks while visiting, a gift shop is available to leave with a memorable gift. This was a great place for us to visit after our medical school exams!
For a real Bahamian experience by the local Toni himself, go get yourself some conch! You can purchase some hot sauce to bring home with you as well. Sometimes he is even hosting a conch cracking experience for visitors to experience! His hours are unpredictable.