Book a tour to Alligator Reef. No alligators, we promise! Cheeca Lodge coordinates trips every day.
Stop by Hog Heaven if you like to party, or Florida Keys Brewing Co if you just want a beer.
Sarah Cate's favorite spot is the Turtle Hospital, on Marathon Key.
If there's one thing you can't miss, it's feeding the tarpon at Robbie's. Mind the pelicans!
Breakfast Midway Cafe - coffee, pastries, and the best key lime pie Mangrove Mike's - famous lobster omelette, pancakes Lunch Square Grouper - spot for fish tacos, coconut shrimp Take Two - the hangover cure: smash burger, rice bowls Dinner - you can't go wrong! Chef Michaels Marker 88 Kaiyo Grill Lazy Days Lorelei