We highly recommend The Blind Special! They'll let you know if it's sweet or savory, and you can always ask about allergies. But as long as you otherwise order it blind, the dish is half off. We've always enjoyed the delicious surprise!
This is an adorable little candy shop/museum in downtown Jeffersonville. Make sure you watch a demo of them making candy, check out the old school vending machine in the museum, and take note of the flood marking out front.