In 2014, Alex came back from finishing school in Kansas and wanted to live out his dreams of playing soccer. He joined a coed adult league with his brothers and some friends, but little did he know he was going to score something even greater than a goal. Kelli impressed Alex with her amazing soccer skills and he impressed her with his ability to arrive late to every single game. Kelli thought Alex was cute and added him on Instagram. He took advantage of the opportunity and slid in her DMs. Soon after that, Kelli had to have knee surgery. Alex visited her, brought her snacks, kept her company, and wooed her with his humor. On Christmas Eve, Alex gave Kelli a homemade coupon book, and on the last page, he asked her to be his girlfriend. Since that day, they have not left each other's sides. Through numerous sporting events, Yogurtland dates, music festivals, and family functions, their love for each other grew. In July of 2022, Alex surprised Kelli with a trip to Big Bear with some of their closest friends. While Alex took Kelli to go get breakfast, their friends secretly set the vibe for the proposal. They lined the walls with photos and lights leading to a cozy picnic on the balcony of the cabin. When they got back, Kelli saw the photos and immediately burst into tears. Alex got down on one knee and Kelli said yes. At that moment, they decided to become teammates for life.