Nancy and Aaron first met in 2016 when Aaron started working at Chick-fil-A. Nancy and Aaron went on a date to Brownies in New Albany in November 2017. The two officially started dating in December of that year. Since then, the two of them have enjoyed lots of time together at concerts, music festivals, watching The Office on repeat, Jeeping, traveling, camping, eating, going to U of L and IU games, and of course spending time with their two dogs, Hoosier and Hopper. On a trip to Florida in September of 2024, Aaron proposed to Nancy (with the two dogs by their sides), and she said, "Yes, of course!" The two quickly began planning their wedding and cannot wait to share their special day with their friends and family.