It all started with a “like” on Hinge—Matt couldn’t resist Jessica’s bold claim that Reese’s are the key to her heart. She sent the first message, and his punny response sealed the deal. One week later, they met for their first date and spent hours passionately debating which Reese’s has the ultimate peanut butter-to-chocolate ratio. (Spoiler: it’s still a hot topic.) The rest is sweet, peanut-buttery history.