The best fast casual brunch spot on the island. They have everything from breakfast burritos, omelettes, pastries, to salads, as well as coffee & smoothies. Tons of GF options.
The Shelter Island diner. Great option for a casual brunch/lunch. Venmo/Cash only.
Delicious bagels on the island. We usually go halves on a cream cheese nova bagel and a bacon egg and cheese. GF bagels available.
One of the best spots on the island for a casual breakfast or lunch with water views. We recommend the curry chicken salad or one of the hot homemade sandwiches.
Leah & Matt's favorite restaurant on the island for dinner. Everything is delicious, especially the burger! Note: If you go, dress in layers. They have a stone hearth oven inside the restaurant so it can get quite toasty depending on the night.
One of our go-to's on the island for dinner. Highly recommend the tuna tacos!
Classic Italian on the Island.
One of our favorite spots to get seafood on the water. We recommend hanging out at their "Shipwreck Bar" after dinner for a cocktail & to hear live music.
Very delicious upscale restaurant on the Island. We like the duck!
Our favorite brunch spot in Greenport.
There is also a location in Sag Harbor
One of our favorite spots to jetski for lunch (you can also drive here). It has great waterfront views with even better fresh seafood!
A causal restaurant with fresh seafood & live music. We love the food here. A must try is their crabby-mary cocktail!
A waterfront restaurant on the Long Island Sound at the Sound View. The views alone are worth the drive there & the fresh oysters!
The best sushi/ asian food.