They matched on a dating app in early 2016, while Caroline was traveling briefly for work in the DC area. John sent her a message, she didn't respond. Fast forward to 2019, Caroline is living in DC, and they matched on another dating app. John sent her a message. She didn't respond again. Eventually, he sent her a message again and, finally noticing that John was a bearded Rugby Player (could he BE any more her type), Caroline finally responded. Apparently, she wanted to play hard to get - He asked her out every day for a month, and finally (perseverance pays off) she agreed to meet among friends for a drink. If "Love at First Sight" is a real thing, this was it! The rest is history!