Hotel
Chill little inn a 90-second walk behind Atlantic, right next to a good bicycle rental shop.
Hotel
A one stop-shop for booking many of the hotels in town, all about a half mile from the wedding! Tons of different room types and sizes available here.
Hotel
4-min walk down the hill from Atlantic. Great views, fewer rooms. Open year-round!
Hotel
5-min walk down the hill from Atlantic. Cute yard.
Hotel
Right in town/the center of the Old Harbor strip.
Hotel
We've never been here, but it's an 8-min walk down the hill right at the start of the downtown Old Harbor strip. Definitely the most party vibe on the island.
House Or Rental
Near the airport. 5-10 min in the car.