As far as we can deduce, Luke and Kelli's profiles were matched by location one fine day (on a popular dating app which we won't mention), as Luke was stuck in traffic on the FDR returning to Connecticut, not too far from Kelli's Manhattan apartment. Kelli had strict rules about never dating anyone from her home state and Luke had begun to grow weary of city girls, but they both went against their better judgement when they realized they'd serendipitously be in the Hamptons Memorial Day weekend to kick off summer 2016. Kelli coaxed Luke into attending a local pool party...Luke stuck around for dinner...Kelli canceled her Jitney back to the city upon a lunch invitation from Luke...Luke prepared striped bass that he landed himself the day prior (show-off) and needless to say, the hooks were set.