You know the story of Cinderella? The one where she loses a shoe, and Prince Charming swoops in to save the day? Well, the way Kayleigh and Derek met was kind of like that... but with a twist. It all began after a night out when Kayleigh got home and discovered the zipper on her boot was stuck. While Cinderella needed to get her shoe on, Kayleigh needed hers off! Suspecting that Derek might just be her Prince Charming, she decided to give him a call. By the time Derek arrived, Kayleigh had already managed to free herself from the stubborn boot, but all that effort had worked up an appetite. Luckily, Derek was hungry too. They headed to Whataburger, where Derek generously bought Kayleigh some fries. They talked about Derek's undying love for John Mayer, Kayleigh's undying love for Hamilton, and their mutual love of fries. Even then, they both had a feeling that night was the start of something special.