John came up looking for a seat during orientation at the table where Susan was sitting. He asked if the seat was taken and she said "Yea..." but before she could get the 'by you' out, he started to walk away. She called him back told him to sit and they hung out for the rest of the orientation. Megan, a friend of Susan's, played the game M.A.S.H. where Susan's 'fortune' was that she would be married to John. They saved each other in their phones as Susan Wife and John Husband. Before Susan's mom left orientation, Susan introduced John to her as her son-in-law. Her mom pulled her to the side to gently remind her that this was a joke. Eight years later, WHO'S LAUGHING NOW?!?!?!
John was determined to take a trip out to California to see Katie, Rosie, and Sydney, all friends from Ringling. First, they stopped in Seattle to meet Susan's family on her dad's side. After Seattle, they went to California, where they visited Disney Land. With the help of Sydney, Katie, and Rosie, John proposed to Susan in front of the Snow White's Wishing Well. This happening after, unbeknownst to Susan, a few failed proposal attempts. Ironically, the day before the proposal, Susan giving the nick-name (which John detested) 'Flex Arrangement' from the movie, Frozen because 'there was no ring'.