Flight
NYC has three airports but Laguardia is definitely the easiest for domestic flights and is a short car ride from all hotel and rental suggestions.
Flight
Second best airport option. A little longer commute but more available flights. If you're up for an adventure, you can take the AirTrain to the subway and skip the Uber ride!
Hotel
Just a 2 minute walk to OTB
Hotel
10 minute walk to OTB
Hotel
22 minute walk to OTB but you'll have a great view of the Manhattan skyline!