During the Michigan January 2019 Polar Vortex, the couple could be found on vacation in Cancun, Mexico. Ashley got up early to go to a sunrise yoga class and in the meantime Hunter prepared a poster. After returning from class, Hunter presented the "Will you marry me" poster and before he could ask, she was already crying, kissing him, and saying yes. They celebrated with champagne before coming back home to freezing weather in Michigan.