Seemingly, it was when Caleb liked Taylor's profile on the dating app Hinge. If you look back at the Orono high school yearbook, you might be shocked to believe we never crossed paths. Even with Taylor's brother playing hockey with Caleb's best friends, even with Caleb's cousin in Taylor's grade, even when Caleb went to Taylor's family house, even when Caleb's roommate and friend were on Taylor's co-ed soccer team, they never met in person until their first date at Centennial Lakes Park (where they took engagement photos!).