Gallery

Andy and Ally's first picture together when they first started dating in 2006

When Andy and Ally first started dating in 2006 (when Ally lived with four boys in Kent)

When Andy came to visit Ally the summer she lived outside of NYC (2007)

Andy and Ally's first time going to Cedar Point together (2007)

Getting mercilessly pelted in the face with thousands of mayflies while on the Millennium Force at Cedar Point (2007)

When Andy came to visit Ally while she was in grad school in Buffalo and they got back together (2011)

Reunited and loving it (2011)

Taking Andy out for his 26th birthday when he lived in Cuyahoga Falls (2011)

Together at Niagara Falls (when Ally lived 15 minutes from it) in 2011

On River Street in Savannah (2012)

At dear friends' wedding in Point Pleasant, WV (2012)

Andy and Ally's failed attempt at having professional photos taken (~2014)

Andy taking Ally out for her birthday when they lived in their North Canton apartment (2015)

The first time Andy took Ally to the Metropolitan Opera (2016)

Having tons of fun being back in NYC (2016)

Closing day on Andy and Ally's first house (2018)

Closing day on Andy and Ally's current house (2019)

Andy and Ally's first Christmas in their current house (2019)

Andy and his spirit animal (~2021)

Discovering pickleball during COVID (2021)

Andy's weakness (~2022)

On the plane to Scotland in Aug. 2022. Andy knows he's going to propose, while Ally has no idea but is hopeful.

Entering the Highlands of Scotland (2022)

The evidence (at the top of Urquhart Castle, overlooking Loch Ness, in Inverness, Scotland, 2022)

Aboard the Jacobite train in Fort William, Scotland, two days after Andy proposed (2022). Andy had originally planned to propose aboard the train but couldn't wait.

Andy and Ally gearing up for their Halloween/Engagement/Ally's Birthday Party (2022)

At dear friends' wedding in Emerald Isle (2023)

Engagement pictures taken by Hilary O'Connell at Andy and Ally's favorite park in North Canton (2023)