Cass and Carli met on Hinge, a dating app, in August 2018. He asked her out for ice cream or a drink, and she was lured in by his photo with Mama and Larry Bird (two Shih Tzus he had just adopted - he knew what he was doing with that photo). They met up at Map Room for their first date. He committed theft for her (pocketed one of the issues of National Geographic displayed at the bar that she thought was cool), walked her home (her mom was mad at her for allowing a stranger to know where she lived, his mom was proud for raising a gentleman), and the rest is history!