Cady moved back to Friday Harbor in the fall of 2022, ready for a fresh start and maybe a little excitement. She began helping coach the high school volleyball team and reconnected with her friend Nadine Varsovia, who clearly had an ulterior motive. Nadine spent every bus ride hyping up her “amazing, single, and totally not weird” friend Kyle to Cady. After weeks of relentless matchmaking propaganda, Cady caved and agreed to meet him. The big day came on October 29, 2022, when Cady showed up at the Bluewater Bar and Grill. There she was greeted by Nadine’s boyfriend, Brock, and an unsuspecting Kyle, who had apparently decided to rock a questionable mustache for the occasion. (Bold move, Kyle.) After breakfast, they headed to a middle school football game, where sparks immediately flew between Cady and Kyle. By the end of the game, Kyle casually invited Cady to go hunting with him and Brock. Hunting? Cady had never gone hunting, but when a cute guy asks, you say yes, right? Brock, ever the smooth wingman, added, “Her dad’s got a sweet piece of land… we gotta get in on that.” Romance was in the air—or maybe it was just deer season. As luck would have it, a buck appeared on Cady’s dad’s property, perfectly timed to give Brock a reason to shoot and Kyle and Cady a reason to keep hanging out. Cady didn’t just watch from the sidelines, either. She was “elbow deep, holding the flashlight” while Kyle cleaned the deer. That’s love, folks. The next day, they spent the entire day together, processing the meat and cheering on the Seattle Seahawks like a couple who had already been together for years. Fast forward two years, and these two are still glued together—and now, they’re making it official! From mustache beginnings to hunting adventures, Cady and Kyle are proof that true love can start with a deer and a whole lot of awkward charm.