Amanda and Kelly matched on Hinge in October of 2021. Kelly liked Amanda's picture of her graduation from college. Amanda messaged first about Kelly's prompt, "What are you buying for the table?..." Kelly said, "A round of shots and a pitcher of beer." Amanda asked, "What kind of beer are you buying for us?" Kelly responded, "A fine pilsner." Amanda then said, "No way! That is my favorite beer!" And so, the love story began!