On a lovely September evening in 2022, Joe orchestrated a plan to propose to Sam. He made a reservation at The Castle and brought home a bouquet of roses. Knowing Sam desired a surprise, Joe sat her on the couch, shared his love, and asked her to accompany him to choose her own ring from the diamond district. Sam was taken aback but Joe didn't make her wait long before popping the question. They had a good laugh, celebrated the occasion, and enjoyed drinks and food as the future Mr. and Mrs. DeMeo.