Priyanka thought she was on a girl’s trip to San Diego, but Zach had a much bigger plan. After a mix-up with her Uber leaving her a mile away from where she thought she was meeting her friend (but really it was Zach waiting to propose), Priyanka was tired and took a break on a bench. Zach, secretly waiting at Sunset Cliffs—where his parents got engaged 35 years ago—realized Priyanka wasn’t walking any further. So, he came to her. When she saw him, her first words were, “What are you doing here?!” Zach smiled and said, “It’s Tuesday”—their inside joke about when they would be getting engaged. In shock, Priyanka followed him back to the cliffs. With the sun setting behind them, Zach got down on one knee and asked her to spend forever with him. And she said yes!