One spooky Halloween night, they both got invited to a Halloween party. Josh, not knowing Nicole was going to be there, fully committed to a clever and witty costume, Mr. Clean, with a Magic Eraser and all. Nicole was something boring, like a cat or something. Nicole then tricked Josh with a story about her camping to lure him in. Flash forward a little over a year and a half and they were moving to San Diego with Nicole's dog Brady! After a little under 3 years together and only 1 camping trip together to show for it, Josh was still the happiest guy with his life with Nicole and Brady. When they were roughing it, as Nicole is known to do, on the Amalfi Coast, Josh popped the question and she said yes! It was worth it, because not only did she say yes, they also went on a 2nd camping trip together after that, and there are even talks of a 3rd.