At a party! Ethan spent the night letting Andi win at darts...they went on one pre-covid date and the rest is history!
While spending the weekend in Ellicottville, NY, little did Andi know, the proposal was set up back at the cabin (photo cred to Tony and Ali)... even better, he surprised Andi with family waiting at dinner to celebrate! To top things off, the night ended with a Bills win!