Kaitlyn and Rob were both searching for love in the wrong places, so they decided to try out this dating app called Bumble. On this dating app, the ladies have to make the first move, which means Kaitlyn had to message Rob first. Rob's dating profile stood out to Kaitlyn, not only because he was handsome, but because in his bio he mentioned that he can make the best grilled cheese sandwiches. Of course, that made Kaitlyn like him from the "get-go" and her first message to him was a fun game of "two truths and a lie". After talking for a while, they had their first date at Revolution in Morristown. Originally, they were supposed to meet at Sona but Kaitlyn was unaware that the restaurant was permanently closed down. During their date, they talked for hours. Both of them realized they had a remarkable connection and didn't want the night to end. Kaitlyn and Rob are excited to be getting married near the town where they met!