Ashley and Tony’s "happily ever after" began just two days after Ashley’s 30th birthday at a bar (PB&J). Tony decided to "spread" some charm and approach her, and proving their personalities—stuck together like peanut butter and jelly. It didn't take long to realize their connection was "extra crunchy" from the start. When they aren't crushing goals at Basecamp or jet-setting to their next destination, they’re the reigning champions of the early bird dinner. They’ve mastered the art of being tucked in to bed by 9:00 PM after a marathon of true crime documentaries, where they’ve "solved" more cases than the FBI. While they agree on almost everything, they remain fiercely competitive over who can catch the best tan in the sun. They’ve officially traded bar tabs for life partnership, proving that their love is the real "toast" of the town.