Abbigail’s Version “Mikey and I met while playing volleyball at the Oasis in Colorado. From that moment on, Mikey was always in the back of my mind as someone I could spend the rest of my life with—but life isn’t always that simple. We spent months as ‘friends’ before I realized he was it. I then spent a month, inadvertently, convincing him that he was mine. A few days before New Year’s Eve, it was a done deal. The rest is our history.” Mikey’s Version “My volleyball partner at the time couldn’t make it, so she found a random substitute to fill in for her. I walked into The Oasis saying ‘hi’ to everyone (shocker), loudly asking if anyone was Abbigail or knew her. There was a pretty girl sitting on a table, though, not paying attention to me… so I kept asking around until I built up the courage—hoping it was her. To my excitement, it was! But she was so unimpressed, and I got so nervous that I played terribly. So I turned on the charm, asking her questions and making sure that if I sucked at volleyball, at least she would think I was funny and nice. She made me feel like I played great and was funny and nice. Turns out, I sucked… but thankfully she liked me, and that’s how it all began.”