One of the rare times both Tyler and Alli had a full day off together, Tyler told Alli he had an early Christmas present planned. That morning, he surprised her by sharing that he had booked a night at Church Landing in Meredith, NH. He presented it as a relaxing night away before all of the Christmas events would be in full swing. Alli had a small thought that maybe this was the day but then quickly convinced herself it wasn't because Danny, her brother, was getting his wisdom teeth out that same day. They wouldn't plan it with that happening, obviously (right?). Fast forward, they're at Church Landing getting ready to head out to dinner when Tyler asked Alli if she wanted to walk down by the water to see the sunset. Walking along the grounds, Tyler suggested they walk down to a small beach. It was there that Tyler asked Alli to marry him! Of course Alli said yes. Meanwhile, both of their parents and siblings were impatiently waiting for their call and were so excited when they all finally connected. All parties who knew managed to keep the secret, including Danny, who was in fact not a decoy and really did get his wisdom teeth out that day! Tyler and Alli were able to share a perfect, intimate engagement that was everything they both could have hoped for.