Woken up from her afternoon nap on the first day in the Grand Caymans, Allyssa woke up to Tyler asking her to take pictures at sunset outside on a pier nearby. Disgruntled and groggy, she walked outside in her best gym tank and shorts, with no contacts or glasses on, and headed to the pier Tyler was eagerly waiting to take pictures at. Only moments later, when Allyssa felt Tyler's heart beating out of his chest, was he down on one knee asking her to marry him. The first words out of her mouth were "Don't even right now" followed by tears and a big YES!