It all really went down in Wisconsin. Nathan was there to celebrate the wedding reception of Jessica and David Lopez, for what he thought was going to be a "guy's weekend" at the Air B+B. What he did not know was that the mysterious girl from the Lopez's Californian wedding reception was going to be there to support the bride! When Katelyn walked in, she spotted Nathan chilling in his Marvel jammies. "Oh no! It's the girl!" he thought. While Katelyn was thinking, "This dude has the right idea hanging out in pajamas." Coincidentally, Nathan and Katelyn both bought the same chocolate bar. When they all returned to the Air B+B, Katelyn hid her candy bar in the kitchen, but later found it laying on the coffee table half-eaten! "Well, if someone else is eating my chocolate bar, I am going to eat my chocolate too!" she thought. Then Nathan walked in. "Excuse me. What are you doing eating my chocolate?" he asked. "Your chocolate? This is my chocolate!" Katelyn exclaimed. "No, it's mine. I bought it today." Nathan calmly explained. He thought to himself, "I like this girl but who does she think she is eating my chocolate?" "Well, I bought one that looks just like that today too. Let me go check the kitchen," Katelyn replied. Sure enough it was still hidden, wrapped tightly in the plastic grocery bag, and tucked in the corner where she left it. She returned to Nathan with her head hung, ashamed for accusing him of eating her chocolate when it was she who had eaten his. She opened her chocolate bar, broke off a square, and handed it to Nathan. "Here is to replace the chocolate I took from you." From then on, Nathan knew Katelyn was the woman for him.