Wills initial pick-up line to Carly was "Wow we have so much in common" and when Carly said "how so" he then went and copy and pasted her whole entire dating profile into the chat. I mean.... clearly it worked because here we are! Our first date was spent talking about our shared love of music and God. Carly and Will both walked away from the date knowing that it was something special. The more they got to know each other, the more they realized just how compatible they are. Both being owners of female cats and sharing a niche fascination of birds, they quickly realized that God put them together for a reason.