Tylor and Catherine met in 2019 while attending Bowling Green State University. Tylor was in his first year studying business, while Cat was in her second year studying exercise science. The two started dating within a few months. They worked together at the beloved Uptown Downtown Bar, creating many memories and friends. Tylor, going on to graduate and pursue his career, moved back home to Cleveland. Catherine pursued her master's degree. This ultimately created a "medium-distance" relationship. Upon Catherine's graduation, she began her career with the Cleveland Clinic, and the two once again reunited. They moved in together to the west side of Cleveland with their two dogs, Mila and Koda. After a long courtship, Tylor finally “popped the question” on the beach in Hilton Head on June 22, 2024.