It was a rainy day and Colin told Jenn they were going to see the new otter pups at the local aquarium in Kure Beach. When they were nearly there, Colin decided to pull over in Fort Fisher. Jenn thought he was crazy given the bad weather outside but surprisingly went along with it and thought "why not." It was here on the rocks that Colin decided to get down on one knee and pop the question. Jenn was so happy and of course said "yes!" Afterwards, Colin and Jenn went to celebrate at a local dive bar where all of their families had traveled to surprise her. Unfortunately, Jenn never did get to see the otter pups and is still waiting for Colin to take her...