Victor popped the question on New Year’s Eve at the very bar where they first spent meaningful time together—because nothing says destiny like returning to where it all began. As the DJ cued up “The Promise” by When In Rome, fate took a wild, pop-star-level turn: Victor randomly met Chris Kirkpatrick from NSYNC while Ashley was in the restroom. Even better? Chris volunteered to bring out the ring himself. When Ashley returned, she was hit with a proposal… and an NSYNC moment. She momentarily struggled to say “yes”—not because of Victor (obviously), but because she was still starstruck by Chris Kirkpatrick standing there with her ring. Once reality kicked back in, it was a resounding YES, sealing a New Year’s Eve engagement that was equal parts romantic, legendary, and totally them.