House Or Rental
Airbnb has a variety of nice places to stay. We recommend booking sooner rather than later, as the area is usually fairly busy and places fill up quickly. Powell and Dublin are both safe and respectable areas. Other nearby towns with a fair amount of rentals include Delaware, Westerfield, Worthington, and Hillard, depending on how far you wish to drive.
Hotel
The Fairfield is right off I-270, close to the church. There are many restaurants and things to do close by, should you find yourself needing to fill any extra time.