JJ and Suzanne headed to an Italian-American social club for a formal “dinner” under the disguise of meeting a friends new girlfriend. JJ decided they should walk through Central Park for some pre-dinner pictures as they were running early. JJ and Suzanne approached “The Pond”, a spot that they had often visited in their 2 years dating. Much to JJ’s surprise, there were several tourists in the pre-planned spot he had picked out to propose to Suzanne at. Always on his toes, JJ decided to stall for some "selfies" which, in hindsight, should have already ruined the surprise. When the spot finally cleared, JJ led Suzanne towards the water and told her to turn around for another picture. When she turned back around, JJ was on his knee, ring in hand, and asked her to marry him. Thankfully she said yes though, much to her chagrin, they never went to dinner... Family and friends snuck in and secretly set up decorations in their Hoboken apartment while the proposal was happening. JJ and Suzanne opened the door to their loved ones all ready to celebrate.