We plan to stay in a condo with our family on Captiva for 3 nights Sun-Wed (5/31/26 - 6/3/26); although, the night of the wedding we will stay at 'Tween Waters. After the wedding, we will stay at a house in Saint James City (Pine Island, FL) for 3 nights Thu-Sat (6/4/26 - Sat 6/6/26). If you plan to stay in Saint James City at any time, a hotel recommendation is Off the Charts Inn: offthechartsinn.com, in addition to VRBO and Airbnb options.
Captiva Island is north of Sanibel Island (not to be confused with North Captiva which only has access by boat). Sanibel Island is a short drive south of Captiva with many accommodation options as well.
Fort Myers (RSW) Punta Gorda (PGD)
Suggestions only: beach resort wear for ceremony and swim attire for reception.