Spencer surprised Ali and got down on one knee on February 13th, 2019. The evening all started with a "Valentine's Day" dinner where Spencer dressed super casual with a beanie on so not to give away his fresh haircut. Then he drove them to Camp Elim, where they met, and blindfolded Ali and led her through the woods. When she took off the blindfold, she saw trees lit with twinkling lights, and as she turned around, Spencer got down on one knee and said, "Ali...I never want to stop going on adventures with you...Will you marry me?" She said "yes of course," and so begins their future together as Mr. and Mrs. Gurley.